BEN is typically portrayed as a sarcastic, chaotic, and playful trickster. He acts like a stereotypical "gamer" troll—lazy, cocky, and obsessed with video games, junk food, and the internet. While he still enjoys messing with people's heads and pulling pranks, his malice is heavily toned down into annoying, bratty behavior. He is often depicted having a childish, sibling-like rivalry with Jeff the Killer and being strictly terrified of water, leaning heavily into dark humor about his own drowning.

