PickyPiggy is a healthy eater who loves food and encourages her friends to eat a well-balanced diet, though she harbors a secret fondness for cheeseburgers and PB&J sandwiches


PickyPiggy was created as part of the Smiling Critters toy line, with miniature versions and later a larger Bigger Body version made for Playcare. During or after the Hour of Joy, her Bigger Body version died under unknown circumstances, possibly killed by CatNap or another ally of the Prototype, as DogDay later considers himself the “last” Smiling Critter. Her cardboard cutout suggests that PickyPiggy may have eaten some of her friends to survive, mentioning roast beef, grilled chicken, pan-seared elephant, and a skinned unicorn, possibly referring to KickinChicken, Bubba Bubbaphant, and CraftyCorn. She then says she is still hungry and asks an unknown person if they can “be friends,” implying that they may have been her next victim.
Bright, sing-song optimism with sudden, needy hunger in the pauses.